A Tale of Two Coaches: What Kind Are You?

There’s more to coaching than sharing your expertise. The way you communicate that expertise is as important as the knowledge itself.

How Your Leadership Is Impacted by the Way You Coach

Photo Courtesy of ©iStockphoto.com/vm

Years ago I went golfing with my friend and colleague, Dr. Victor Oliver. I had played quite a bit as a teenager, but had set aside my clubs when I became an adult. At the age of forty-three I decided to take it up again.

I bought a new set of clubs, reviewed the rules, and even read a couple of golfing books. However, I was still lacking the one thing you must have to succeed at the game of golf: confidence.

I sliced my first drive, red-faced as the ball bounced into the tall grass and disappeared. Unfazed, Victor declared. “You have a great swing, Mike. You’re a natural. You’ll get the hang of this in no time.”

Rather than dwelling on my failed attempt, Victor’s assurance immediately turned my mind to the next shot. I couldn’t wait to take another swing.

After a few more shots, I was within striking distance of the green. As I approached the ball and began to setup for the shot, Victor gently interrupted me.

“For these kinds of shots, I always imagine I am sitting on the edge of a bar stool. I lean forward with my back straight and head down. Then I just take a nice, full swing … like this.”

“Got it,” I nodded. I then mimicked his stance, took a slow, steady swing, and put the ball right on the green, eight feet from the pin.

“Beautiful, Mike. I told you you were a natural.”

Over the next several years, I played golf with Victor numerous times. I always played my best when I was with him at my side. His gentle, reassuring voice gave me the one thing books, expensive clubs, and even lessons couldn’t: confidence.

I also occasionally played golf with another friend. I’ll call him Frank (not his real name). He was a good deal older than I, but a great golfer—even better than Victor. But the two were complete opposites when it came to coaching.

I still remember the last time I played with him. On hole number three, I sliced a drive into the deep rough. Certain it was unplayable, I dropped my club to the ground, and sighed.

“Well, that was a helluva shot,” Frank grumbled. “You didn’t finish your swing. You just kinda … kinda gave up on it.” He then frowned and snorted.

With that, he stepped up to the tee box and pinned his tee and ball to the ground in one seamless motion. Then, without so much as a practice swing, he blasted his ball straight down the middle of the fairway.

It was picture-perfect. Just like on TV. Speaking to no one in particular, he announced, “That’s how it’s done!”

He stood tall.

I felt small.

Unfortunately, this scenario was typical. Frank was always quick to point out my faults. If I happened to hit the ball well, he would say something like, “Well, you got lucky on that one, didn’t ya, kid?”

Not surprisingly, I always played my worst golf when I played with Frank. He chipped away at my confidence, and my performance unraveled as the game progressed. He made me want to quit.

In reflecting on these two different coaching styles, I realized I have a choice in how I lead.

I can either focus on what my teammates are doing right and thus increase their confidence, or I can focus on what they are doing wrong and thus increase their self-doubt. Both styles have an impact on their performance. And both have an impact on my effectiveness as a leader.

Question: What style do you use in coaching those you lead? You can leave a comment by clicking here.

Want to launch your own blog or upgrade to self-hosted WordPress? Watch my free, twenty-minute screencast. I show you exactly how to do it. You don’t need any technical knowledge. Click here to get started.

Please note: I reserve the right to delete comments that are snarky, offensive, or off-topic. If in doubt, read My Comments Policy.

  • Pingback: What Kind of Coach Are You? « Kanakuk Institute

  • Pingback: Michael Hyatt: International Leadership Selected Blogs | Douglas Memery' UCD ePortfolio

  • Pingback: Your Encouragement Matters - Homeschool Creations

  • Alison

    I count myself lucky to have a coach like Dr. Oliver. She encourages and motivates me. I’m always learning from her – and she says the same about me.

  • http://www.drchristyd.com/ Dr. Christy Demetriades

    This is so true Michael. It’s really disappointing when you need help, and you reach out for it and a well intentioned person “pokes” your weakness thinking that they are prompting you to grow. (Uhh… no.) It’s not like we don’t know it’s our weakness… (It’s like watering weeds and expecting flowers to grow.) It’s MUCH more encouraging and growth promoting when someone acknowledges what we ARE doing right, acknowledges this, and gently encourages us along this path. Sometimes, when this is done in a loving manner, that initial “weakness” might strengthen over time. But the weak areas will never grow in an atmosphere of negativity, guilt or condemnation. Love and acceptance is where growth is fostered and developed.

    • http://michaelhyatt.com/ Michael Hyatt

      Great points, Christy. Thanks for commenting.

  • Tony Hendley

    Great analogy. I’ve golfed with both of those guys…lol The one that focuses on strengths is the one that i prefer to golf with and I improve throughout the day the other one does not for me cause me to be better.

  • J. Michael McDade

    Great blog Michael. As a counselor, I find people are tough enough on themselves without the added negative comments I could add. Encouragement always brings out the best in people. Thanks for the reminder.

  • Matt Ream

    Thank you Mr. Hyatt. There is some real truth in how a coach or mentor delivers their message. After reading your post a few days ago, I had the luxury of going cycling. During our ride, I (as a former Master’s Racer in Nor. Cal.) had the opportunity to help via coaching or mentoring (you choose) an slightly older gentleman who was struggling. Over two hours, we finished and he was extremely grateful… yet more than that, the other guys in our group came to me individually and made comments. And that was extremely gratifying. Gratification, a wonderful side affect of being a positive influence. I think more time than not, manager/leaders get caught up in deadlines and fail on being a mentor… which often times is a very small time constraint, and one which would offer invaluable personal satisfaction in helping someone out. Again, thank you for your post. Cheers!