That eBook Thing Will Never Catch On

It’s no secret that I am a big fan of the Amazon Kindle 2. However, whenever I write about it (as I did recently here and here), I always have someone who says, “I will never convert to an eBook reader. I just love the feel of a book in my hands.”

someone holding the amazon kindle 2 in their hand

I totally understand that sentiment, but imagine this:

  • In 1442, “I will never get used to a book. It doesn’t feel right. I just love the experience of unrolling a scroll and the beauty of hand-written words.” Johannes Gutenberg invented movable type and the mechanical printing press in 1439.
  • In 1881, “I will never convert to electric lights. It just isn’t natural. I love the smell of candles and the flickering of the light.” Thomas Edison invented the electric light bulb in 1879.
  • In 1916, “I will never buy an automobile. It’s too dangerous. I just love of the feel of a buggy and the sound of the horse’s hoofs against the road.” Henry Ford began mass producing cars in 1914.

You may never convert to an eBook reader, but what about your children or grandchildren. I’m just sayin.’

Question: What about you? What would it take for you to convert?
Disclosure of Material Connection: Some of the links in the post above are “affiliate links.” This means if you click on the link and purchase the item, I will receive an affiliate commission. Regardless, I only recommend products or services I use personally and believe will add value to my readers. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255: “Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising.”

Get Free Email Updates!

Exclusive bonus! Subscribe today and you’ll receive a link to download my brand new e-book, Creating a Personal Life Plan, FREE. This step-by-step guide will help you design the life you’ve always wanted.

WestBow Press

Please note: I reserve the right to delete comments that are snarky, offensive, or off-topic. If in doubt, read My Comments Policy.

  • http://acnescarfading.pressyt.com Exodus

    You have really great taste on catch article titles, even when you are not interested in this topic you push to read it

  • Pingback: I have seen the light and become an eBook reader– with a caveat | macdavid pro

  • Makus

    You made some good points there. I did a search on the topic and found most people will agree with your blog.
    http://www.free-plr-article.com/

  • http://twitter.com/thinkmonk Dave Jacobs

    I’m a big reader and once had the same objections you listed above. But now I’m happy to say I’m a believer in e-readers. I have the latest kindle which allows me to underline, add notes, even cut and copy.

  • Jeff Clarke

    I’ve already converted and I enjoy the Kindle as well!

  • http://www.best-registrycleaner.net Best Registry Cleaner

    I really want a Kindle.

  • Pingback: Tweets that mention That eBook Thing Will Never Catch On -- Topsy.com

  • http://michaelsale.myopenid.com/ Mike S.

    I have and often use my current gen wireless-only kindle… but I still prefer printed page for non-fiction books for the following reasons:
    1. Chapter and section headings (more then page numbers!)
    2. Page Numbers
    3. Fast bookmark navigation – Kindle takes WAY too long to find the bookmark and navigate to it

  • http://twitter.com/joancwebb Joan C. Webb

    What would it take for me to convert? Hmmm. Extra bucks to buy an iPad. Although as an author, I love words on pages bound into little packages, I “fell in love” (so to speak) with my husband’s iPad while on vacation. I read 5 books in about 10 days. I’m convinced. Still like holding the book, but…

  • Joni Hannigan

    I admit I’m holding out a while longer for an iPad. Tried a Nook over Christmas and 1) Couldn’t find books I wanted, and 2) Couldn’t turn pages fast enough. So perhaps the iPad which is slightly larger, will accommodate me. It also handles a lot of eBook apps (and does a lot of other things), so I think I’ll be happier than limiting myself to a Kindle.

    As for the nostalgia, I agree with Julie Barnhill. And let me add that I’m not sure an eBook will ever replace the shelves of signed first editions either and the thrill I get when I pick one up and remember the moment I was there. Or the rage at seeing that one of my children tore off the cover or put it down in water. No, really, I consider it a plus that someone read it. Used book, splattered books, even torn books are a mark of distinction on my shelves. I lovingly placed a 27-year-old coverless Bible story book printed on oilskin paper in my 2 year-old granddaughter’s hands this past weekend. She promptly smoothed it down and asked me to read it to her.

    Booklovers can be pioneers, however! We live in this great age. I look forward to cleaning out the bookshelves and decided what I MUST keep–and what I can recycle/discard and either replace digitally or make a list to look for if/when I get time to look at it. And with the time I save worry about how to store and catalog and categorize all those books, I can spend time reading eBooks on whatever device I end up with–wherever I am–on a plane, on the beach, on a ship, or waiting in a doctor’s office.

    Joni

  • Michael

    I find it interesting how many book-ish features are trying to find their way into e-books, mostly because of our love affair with print. Page turns, book marks that look like book marks, dog-ears, highlights that look like they’re made by a highlighter. I even heard one person suggest that e-readers should have screens on the back for others to see the cover of what someone else is reading. These features will surely be replaced by something better and more relevant as those who have no idea what a “book” is become the dominant user.

  • Brian

    I’d have to say it seems the publishers are the ones driving the ebook sales. As they continue to release books in hardcover format only, more and more people aren’t willing to pay the $25+ per book and see the $10 ebook as a great deal. My problem is that in pushing the ebook format more and more of their brick and mortar accounts will be closing as we are seeing. It may be very beneficial for a publisher to sell ebooks instead of paper due to the lower cost, no returns, no damages, no defective print runs, etc, etc but in the future, once all the brick and mortar stores are closed where will someone go to browse a shelf and find that new book or new author they never knew existed? I can’t do that on Amazon. I think publishers are really hurting themselves by driving more sales to ebooks. Just my thoughts though.

  • http://passionsofthesoul.typepad.com/vicki Vicki Small

    It took arthritic hands that found holding a book, while reading in bed, increasingly difficult and painful. I wouldn’t say my Kindle 3.1 is really easy to hold, largely because of the forward/back buttons on each side, but it’s easier than most books, for me.

    Last week, I discovered a totally unexpected bonus: I have never been able to read while riding in a car or for very long on an airplane (I’m never on a boat, but I imagine the same would be true). Last week, we made the nearly 1,000-mi. round trip to move my mom to a different facility. I spent several hours, each way, reading my Kindle, with nary a hint of motion sickness!

    My husband has also made the switch, which he hadn’t expected to do

    I do wish the makers would remove the buttons from one side.

  • Tca Johnston

    I work in a book shop and I understand the marketing potential of e books and I too love the feel of a book, but my 13 year old son loves his kindal. I think there is room for both. I had a man in to our book shop last week who had a bible that he has been journalling for 20 years – this cannot be left for generations in a e-book

  • http://passionsforthesoul.typepad.com/vicki Vicki Small

    P.S. I expected more of a price differential between Kindle books and hard cover or paperback books. I don’t understand why Kindle books cost as much as they do, given the lack of paper, binding of any kind, real ink, returns, etc.

    • http://passionsforthesoul.typepad.com/vicki Vicki Small

      Not a reply–more of a request: I had hoped to get a reply to this comment. I don’t intend to be argumentative; I’m sure there is a good explanation; for example, that electronic paper and ink are far more expensive than I would think, especially given that I know nothing about them. But without some information, I go on thinking that Kindle books are more expensive than they ought to be.

  • http://passionsforthesoul.typepad.com/vicki Vicki Small

    By the way, what are the differences between a Kindle 2 and the Latest Generation?

  • http://jackr.myopenid.com/ Jack Repenning

    Well, yes, I’ll always have my calf-bound copy of Milton’s “Paradise Lost.” But I may not be able to buy a replacement without haunting estate sales!

  • http://jackr.myopenid.com/ Jack Repenning

    “What can I get in a store that I can’t get on-line” will need to be something other than “some particular title.” The experience of sitting at the in-store coffee shop is often cited … but I can read my Kindle, and even buy more books, at my neighborhood coffee shop. And plain old coffee shops are already much easier to find than bookstores!

    My vote for “what e-readers need to solve if they ever hope to really catch on” is: browsing shelves full of thousands of books. I have around 1000 physical books in my house, and I already shudder to imagine searching through all of them on an e-reader. E-browsing the inventory of your average Barnes & Noble is down right scary!

  • firerain2

    I find it easier on the eyes to read an ebook. I don’t fall asleep reading and the light is always just right.:-) It’s a lot easier to read while on the treadmill too. And I don’t even use a Kindle or a Nook but use their apps on my iTouch. Great way too to read classics in the public domain – all free for the taking!

  • Don

    I have a kindle…and I like it a great deal…BUT:

    1. Kindle is the only ereader that will not let you check “books” out at the library.

    2. I cannot tell you how many times the kindle version of the book is equal or more expensive than the real book. This should absolutely never be the case!!! With an ebook there is not paper/ink to buy, no cover, no binding, no shipping, etc. An ebook should NEVER be even 50% the cost of a real book.

    3. Once you are done reading an ebook you cannot sell it like you can a real book.

    Due to both of these (especially #2) I am seriously thinking about selling my kindle and going back to the real books. At least if I am going to pay that much, I can still sell it when I am done!!!!

  • http://joeandancy.com Joe Abraham

    Those three quotes are something to think about! I have made such blunder statements (many times to myself and few times to others) and later had to do what I said I will never do! I think we have an obsession to our “old-is-gold” stuff and we need to deliberately overcome that for more effective systems.

    Speaking about eBook reader, here in India, it’s just in the baby stage. So I am not thinking about it now.

  • http://LookingForPurpose.com Dylan Dodson

    Great analogies!

  • http://twitter.com/jrep Jack Repenning

    Kindle is available (and free, an excellent price!) for laptops from Amazon.

  • http://twitter.com/jrep Jack Repenning

    You really should borrow someone’s actual Kindle. I have Kindle apps on Mac and iPhone, as well as a Kindle 2. There’s no question what so ever, the Kindle 2 is the best reading experience. But one of the coolest things is, all the devices remember where you were on any of them. I routinely fill waiting time by iPhone-Kindle-reading what I was reading on the K2 last night in bed!

  • http://titus2345.blogspot.com ET @ Titus2:3-5

    If I could highlight and write notes on the pages of the books in my e-reader, I think that would convert me. Can you do that in the new ones???

    • http://michaelhyatt.com Michael Hyatt

      Yes!

  • Todd D Vasquez

    To give an indication of where I see the future going, my concern is not whether my children and grandchildren will read their books digitally but whether they will read anything that hasn’t been made digital.

  • http://twitter.com/jrep Jack Repenning

    Kindle *does* allow you to snag and review: whatever you highlight is stored “in the cloud,” at kindle.amazon.com (and in the book as well, of course). The mechanics of highlighting need a lot of work, though. A yellow highlighter is almost completely non-intrusive; the Kindle highlight operation … anything but.

  • Colleen Coble

    I know, I know. I was one of those. :) I love my Kindle now but I still like to read real books too. I don’t think I’ll ever totally give them up. But then I once said NEVER about an ereader. :) 

    I actually think MORE people are reading since the Kindle became so popular. I think it’s going to be a boon to authors and publishers everywhere.

    • http://michaelhyatt.com Michael Hyatt

      I totally agree, Colleen. The only ones I worry about are book retailers.

  • http://twitter.com/jrep Jack Repenning

    The actual Kindle is much much more readable.

    • http://michaelhyatt.com Michael Hyatt

      I agree. The iPhone is good in a pinch when you don’t have your Kindle, but I find the Kindle easier on my eyes.

  • http://twitter.com/jrep Jack Repenning

    Original Kindle, or Kindle 2? The ’2 is dramatically better.

  • Lisa

    I’ve converted, and for some books (like the ones I use for grad school), I love the functionality: to get definitions, or do intext searches on topics, create citations, and the ability to conduct web searches.

    But, I will miss the tactile ability to highlight, make handwritten notes, or be able to “thumb” to certain passages. The electronic way of doing these tasks are taking me a while to develop!

  • http://www.dwaynes--world.blogspot.com Dwayne Morris

    The ticket is the ability to print and index my highlights and notes. Once I crossed ths hurdle, I was hooked. Now it’s almost addictive to search for and buy books.

  • Rejoshmiller

    Those are bad analogies if most of your family is Amish!! LOL!!

  • http://www.dwaynes--world.blogspot.com Dwayne Morris

    You need to check out http://www.yournextread.com. Great tool for finding books based on books you’ve already read.

  • http://www.BrandieLagarde.com Brandie Lagarde

    Okay, I admit it. I was one of those naysayers because I am a crazy person about books. It has to be the right size, pages have to feel right, and the print can’t be too crowded. When I published my book I drove them insane, but my book looks and feels great.
    Then I got a Kindle.
    It opened a whole new reading world for me, it now only matters how well edited and compelling the story is because all books are coverless and look the same. I can’t imagine it taking mankind two years to catch on! I’m like their biggest salesperson, I talk more about it than I do my book!

  • http://twitter.com/gort999 John J Volk

    Abraham Lincoln could never have had the education or the man he was – he read books by candlelight. Today electricity is cheap and prevalent, but there are realistic scenarios in which electricity and electric power ceases to be available. What happens to your books then? If you can’t plug into an electrical outlet and recharge you can’t read! This to me and the fact that I am proud of my library of books I have, sounds a death knell on all things electronic. There is no permanence! Ebooks may be fine for something I will read once, but like to pass my books on to others – and the lending option on Nooks and Kindles is a joke. Only God can make a Tree! Only a Tree can make a book! Therefore God made books!

    • http://michaelhyatt.com Michael Hyatt

      Love your logic! Seriously, why does it have to be either or. When I bought a TV, I didn’t get rid of my radio. I still use both.

  • Bolovesjoe

    I bought the complete works of George MacDonald for $1.99 and The Essential GK Chesterton (400 works) for $.99 on Amazon for my Kindle.  These are books I never would have purchased otherwise (where would I even PUT them all?) but I LOVE having them available whenever I have some time to kill and am looking for a great quote.  Mostly, my Kindle has revolutionized the way I wait for my kids in parking lots – having my whole library available  is just the greatest $114 investment ever. 

  • http://thejourneydeeper.wordpress.com/ darlene

    I’m actually considering a Kindle, however my hesitation is that I am not sure if they are designed in a way that will let me read books the way I normally do – sometimes starting with chapter 1, jumping to chapt 5, etc. And if I want to refer back to a page already read, is there a whole lot of scrolling involved? I guess I need to talk to someone who actually has one and see if they will let me “hold it.” :)

    • http://michaelhyatt.com Michael Hyatt

      Yes, you need to try it for yourself. It’s easier than you think.

  • Jared P

    My struggle is with the number of books on my shelf. I want all my “stuff” in one spot. Am I being too picky?

  • Becky Jenkinson

    But Michael…..I sell books!  I sell books from Thomas Nelson (and other publishers!).  How do I compete or even interest those who want the ebooks???

    • http://michaelhyatt.com Michael Hyatt

      That’s the problem you must solve. No one is going to do it for you.

      I bumped into my local bookseller yesterday. His store is two blocks from my house. I asked him, “So how’s business?” I feared the worst. He smiled and said, “Business has never been better. We’re having the best year we have ever had.”

      It is possible to win, but I think you have to believe you can and then figure out the rest. Some are doing it!

  • http://twitter.com/jrep Jack Repenning

    Me, too, on both accounts. And if we step back from personal preferences for just a moment, and ask “where is this all going?” I think we have to admit that “money is going to talk,” here. If we like physical books and book stores and all the rest, the best thing we can do to save them is to buy them. But, despite my professed preferences, I’m definitely buying more eBooks than pBooks these days — and more eBooks now than I was buying any kind of books, before the eBook wave took me.

  • Gregwood

    Changing to the Kindle wasn’t something I would ever do, but due to the inability to hold a book in my hands for an extended period and because my eyesight is getting worse due to having M.S., I have rediscovered my love for reading. I LOVE my Kindle and have purchased a couple for my parents who have a hard time finding large print books. Now they can simply select a larger font to any book they want. It has also come in handy for travelling with the weight restrictions on luggage. I would need a separate suitcase for the amount of books I have in my Kindle.:-)

    • http://www.jmlalonde.com Joe Lalonde

      Wow, thanks for sharing your story. It is amazing how technology has helped you and your parents rekindle, (-; , your love of reading.

  • Jason H.

    I’m a big believer of e-books and have not purchased a hard copy of a book for personal reading in years. Unfortunately as a doctoral student, I’m stuck having to buy $100 books for each class until major publishing companies in the academia field can figure another way to fund their publishing efforts. :)

  • Daniel Lyle

    What would it take for me to switch?  79 bucks.

  • Daniel Lyle

    What would it take for me to switch?  79 bucks.

  • Ian

    While I don’t have anything against ebooks (in fact I think they are a tremendous oppurtunity for want-to-be-authors like me) I have to admit that I was one of those people who said I’d never convert up until a few days ago. My wife got me a new cell phone that came with a Kindle App. I downloaded several free books just to say I had the ebook experience and to my surprise I am actually enjoying reading them.  :)

    I don ‘t think I will be going 100% digital anytime soon (I enjoy highlighting my non-fiction books way too much) but I can certainly see the value and the potential future of these devices.

    The IPOD has pretty much sealed the fate of the CD as far as I know (anyone got any current stats on that?) and it may very well come to pass in the next generation that printed books are relegated to the dustbin of history.

  • John Mark Harris (dot net)

    I bought my mom (63) a Kindle Touch for χmas this year, they can’t text message, and can barely use voicemail, but necessity is the mother of invention (or something). Mom did get on Facebook after we moved (with her 2 granddaughters) 660 miles away. Mom is always reading, there is always a thick paperback in her purse. The verdict? Mom and dad have been reading to eachother via their new Kindle Touch. They said it was the best gift they’ve ever gotten. My sister and I split it… The “eBook reader” is wonderful once you actually try to use it, may as well have the best one. I got myself the same thing, Kindle Touch with the Amazon Black leather case with the light. It’s great!!! Don’t get me wrong, I love paper books, I have about 12 six-foot bookcases full, but now, if a book has a Kindle version, that’s what I prefer… Great blog!

  • Bonnie Holley

    Already a convert. I can take my whole library with me anywhere. Why would I hang on to a paper book? Besides, most e-books are at least half the price of paper.

  • Bonnie Holley

    Isn’t hanging on to paper books a bit like saying, “Wow, I love my cassette or vhs tapes? ” I have some special paper books for sure, as keepsakes, but the e-reader boosts my reading and my experience of the world!

©2009 Michael Hyatt, Powered by Standard Theme

Want to know how to get your book published? Start here!