The Mystery of Writing

A few nights ago, I sat down with the intention to write a blog post. I had been mulling a specific idea over for several days. I thought it was a slam dunk. I should be done in 30 minutes, I thought, 45 minutes—max.

A Man with His Head on His Laptop and a White Flag of Surrender - - Photo courtesy of ©iStockphoto.com/Captainflash, Image #9029390

Not so much.

If you are just getting started with Evernote, I suggest that you buy Brett Kelly’s remarkably practical e-book, Evernote Essentials, Second Edition. It is worth setting aside a couple hours to work through this brief, 95-page book. It will save you DAYS of learning Evernote on your own.

The first paragraph came quickly. But then I got stuck. I wrote another one, didn’t like it, and deleted it. I spiraled through that same loop ten times. Nothing seemed to work.

About that time, distraction set in. P.J. O’Rourke described it well when he wrote:

Usually, writers will do anything to avoid writing. For instance, the previous sentence was written at one o’clock this afternoon. It is now a quarter to four. I have spent the past two hours and forty-five minutes sorting my neckties by width, looking up the word “paisly” in three dictionaries, attempting to find the town of that name on The New York Times Atlas of the World map of Scotland, sorting my reference books by width, trying to get the bookcase to stop wobbling by stuffing a matchbook cover under its corner, dialing the telephone number on the matchbook cover to see if I should take computer courses at night, looking at the computer ads in the newspaper and deciding to buy a computer because writing seems to be so difficult on my old Remington, reading an interesting article on sorghum farming in Uruguay that was in the newspaper next to the computer ads, cutting that and other interesting articles out of the newspaper, sorting—by width—all the interesting articles I’ve cut out of newspapers recently, fastening them neatly together with paper clips and making a very attractive paper clip necklace and bracelet set, which I will present to my girlfriend as soon as she comes home from the three-hour low-impact aerobic workout that I made her go to so I could have some time alone to write.”

But distraction wasn’t really my problem. At least not initially. I was intent on writing—I just couldn’t.

After writing four books and almost one thousand blog posts, I have learned two things about writing:

  1. Sometimes, I just need to park myself in my chair, fire-up my laptop, and force myself to start. Nine times out of ten, this works for me.
  2. When that doesn’t work—after a concerted effort—I just need to quit. I have to get up and do something else.

This is all part of the mystery of writing. It’s a balancing act, isn’t it?

You want to exercise self-discipline and force yourself to write, even when you don’t feel like it. But you also have to trust the process and recognize when that won’t work. If you are patient—with yourself and with the process—the Muse will eventually speak.

Questions: As a writer, have you learned to trust the process? Is there a time when you got stuck but eventually regained your inspiration? You can leave a comment by clicking here.
Set up a self-hosted WordPress blog in 20 minutes or less by watching my step-by-step screencast. Also, get a discount on BlueHost web hosting. It is the only hosting service I personally recommend. Learn more ….

Please note: I reserve the right to delete comments that are snarky, offensive, or off-topic. If in doubt, read My Comments Policy.

  • http://www.gospellab.com Gospel lab

    I wonder what it was like to be one of those chosen by God to write the words down that would become our Bible we have today. How was their process? Pick up the quill and ink and write until the Holy Spirit said stop?

    Imagine if the Apostle Paul wrote a blog back in the day. Would it be easier or harder for him? He would probably sit there and sit there and then finally admit, “I am just human, I think I prefer to write the words of God instead.”

    • http://michaelhyatt.com Michael Hyatt

      I am not always sure they were penning Holy Scripture. Regardless, it is an interesting question.

  • http://bretmavrich.posterous.com/ Bret Mavrich

    For me a title is everything. If in my initial conceptualization of a topic I can land the title, usually that is the rocket boost necessary to get me to my computer. I may land on a different spin, a different angle, or even a different title than I started with, but a working title is critical for me to even get in the game.

  • http://familysynergy.wordpress.com JD Eddins

    Been there, in fact, I might be there now. That’s why I keep a moleskin note book with me at almost all times. I can write ideas and thoughts for future blog posts or continue thoughts from other things I have written down.
    I’m glad to know that others who have been doing this much longer than me have the same issue.

    • http://michaelhyatt.com Michael Hyatt

      I do the same. Sometimes, I get great ideas in meetings that have nothing to do with the topic at hand. I jot it down, so it doesn’t dissipate into the ether.

  • Gary

    I find that to be very true of journalling. I sometimes have so much on my mind I cannot get it out of mind and onto paper. I find it is then that I must just let my mind wonder and work through those issues that constrain it. That is the time I put pen and paper down, meditate, pray, and just think. Other times thinks flow as if the mind and pen/paper are one. I feel your pain.

  • Anonymous

    This has been the story of my life this week. I finally had to unplug the internet yesterday afternoon and clear my desk of all the “extras” that had been distracting me all day. And, amazingly enough, once I got started, the words started to flow and it all came together!

  • Linley

    I am so glad that I’m not alone in that. Thanks for sharing.

  • Paul Thomas

    “You can’t wait for inspiration. You have to go after it with a club.” -Jack London. I once read he wrote 1,000 words a day, and sometimes all 1,000 went straight from the typewriter to the trash can.

    Writing even when what I write is terrible and will never be used is useful when I’m stuck.

    An odd thing I’ve found is that when I have a particularly good idea, I am overcome with an overwhelming urge to get up and find a distraction. That’s weird. Does it happen to anyone else?

    • http://michaelhyatt.com Michael Hyatt

      I am personally less likely to be distracted with a good idea—but it happens. That’s why I refer to the writing process as a mystery. It’s not science for sure!

      • www.therextras.com

        Hubby and I learned ‘get it down not get it right’. I am an iterative writer. The first draft is exactly that – a draft.

  • http://www.flavors.me/jasmine84 Jennifer Rowsell

    As a student, I have no choice! I have 3 papers due by Thursday night so I gotta get inspired and write fast, haha.
    My blog is purely for fun and so sometimes I write 4 times a week, sometimes I go a whole month and don’t post a thing. I don’t worry about it :)

  • http://twitter.com/mylivingpower Laurie Wallin

    Yep, I’m learning to trust the process. Until recently I went with the muse version too often, and wrote seldom on my blog because of it. Then I scheduled time, and started finding myself in the position of the guy in your picture. Now things are balancing because I’ve got speech to talk apps on my phone, so I “write” while I walk my dog and during other inspiring moments. Then I just rummage through my ideas when it’s time to post. Yay!

    • www.therextras.com

      “Trust the process” – like that line, too. I’ve not had real occasion of ‘writer’s block’ but my blog posts are not on deadline. Laurie, will you send me more information about the speech to talk apps on your phone? (Laurie and I know each other, Michael.)

  • Shawnhope

    Reminds me of a couple quotes, I am not sure of the source for this one but it rings true in many ways: “writers love to have written.” Also, Peter De Vries said “I love being a writer, what I can’t stand is all the paperwork.”

    I often find myself sitting down with a great idea to write about, then, half way through writing the blog, or essay, I scrap it to write of a new idea, that happened to flow freely.

    In a lot of ways, as a writer, I feel as though I am just a facilitator of what the page is going to do naturally. If the process just isn’t working, I let it rest, and save it for another time.

  • http://twitter.com/rkinnick59 Randy Kinnick

    O’Rourke, like me, was not distracted, he was suffering from ADHD! ;-) At any rate, I agree completely with your approach. I find that I must eventually do one of those two things to deal with the hurdle. It is a mystery, for sure, what brings the flow at times and shallows the waters at others.

  • http://twitter.com/vivifonseca viviana fonseca

    i believe good ideas always make it to the “paper”. they’re in my mind till the time is right. not before. meanwhile, they wander around getting ready for my heart/mind/good-sense-of-proper-grammar to connect them.
    thanks for your post, it’s great. makes me realise i need to try harder. will do.
    excellent blog, by the way, thanks a lot!

  • Doug Armey

    Had this happen today. I had outlined a post yesterday to begin the rough draft on this morning. Sat down to write and I couldn’t even understand why I had written what I had yesterday. No energy. No passion.

    I prayed about what I really wanted to say and just started writing. I quit thinking about what I ought to say and just looked inside for what was burning and needed to get out.

    The good news? It flowed. I’ve never had that happen quite the same way.

    Have others ever experienced that?

    • http://michaelhyatt.com Michael Hyatt

      Absolutely. The danger for me is in thinking I have discovered “the formula.” Almost every writing experience is different. Sometimes it is easy; often it is just work. Occasionally, nothing I do works. Thanks for sharing your experience.

  • Nicole

    So true! At times I have ended up writing articles the day before the deadline for the same reason. Most of the battle is getting myself to start. Usually once I get going it’s easier to finish.

  • http://twitter.com/pastorbrett pastorbrett

    Most of my ideas come when hot water is flowing over me in the morning. As for getting the job done on paper, a mentor advised: “Bolt your tail to the chair; bolt your chair to the floor; don’t get up until you are done.” Easier said than done, for sure. Sometimes a good walk does the trick. As we come to understand better (scientifically) the brain, it will be interesting to see if we will learn how to best harness the creative process.

  • http://kbhyde.wordpress.com Katherine Hyde

    I’m on my third novel now (not counting three I began and abandoned), and I’ve gotten stuck for a significant period somewhere during the process on all of them. Sometimes it’s because I need to work something out about the novel before I can go on. Sometimes, though, I quit writing because I’m too stressed. Stress is the great enemy of creativity. At those times, I have to force myself to breathe, turn the stressful situations over to God, get my butt in the chair and write–and eventually inspiration returns. Then the vicious cycle reverses and writing helps me deal with the stress.

  • http://twitter.com/bnotess Brian Notess

    I’ve definitely been there too. Most of the time I can squeeze something out, sometimes it’s even almost physically painful, but I find, once it’s out, polishing doesn’t take as long as I thought.

  • Gregory Scott

    Michael–Having written almost daily for the last 20 years as a trial lawyer, I can tell you nothing inspires me like an immovable deadline. I find myself stuck a lot more when I’m blogging at home (w/o a deadline) than when I’m drafting a legal brief at work that has to be done by 5 pm. Thanks for sharing your experience and wisdom.

  • http://www.google.com/profiles/deanmehrkens Dean

    I noticed that with the novel I have tucked away in a drawer somewhere. Most of the time I just didn’t want to write, but forced myself to start. An hour or two later I had some of the best pages I had ever written. There is definitely a balance of knowing when to walk away and when to push through.

  • http://www.inhotpursuitofmoreandless.blogspot.com Sharon

    I can identify so well with this! I am still unexperienced in writing, but I have found that when I keep my eyes and heart open to how God is working around me and how He is growing me, the words will flow freely. Times when I allow my life to become rushed, busy and the tyranny of the urgent drives my days, no matter how much time and effort I put into trying to write, nothing comes. I find I need to peel away and write when the words are there, no matter what else I am supposed to be doing at the time. Thanks so much for your advice and encouragement!

  • http://uma-maheswaran.blogspot.com/ Uma Maheswaran S

    I completely concur with your perspective. The only advantage I have is that I am not a professional money making writer but an amateur writer. I do not necessarily have to meet any time bound schedules.

    I start to write when zeal sprouts inside me. I keep nurturing the idea inside my mind. Finally, I love to write in isolation without any disturbance. I always have a writing pad and pencil with me (even in my bed room). Whenever an idea germinates, I put down that in my pad and later develop the same.

    I have written technical articles and blogs (but not books till now.) Many times, it is the result of several rounds of fair drafting. It’s like experimentation for me. I have to accept this trial and error technique to bring out the best in me. Passion and desire to write keeps me ticking to produce articles. I remember, one time, I woke up during midnight and started writing immediately by switching the lamp. I didn’t even get out of my couch and persisted for 2 hours to complete my writing in one go. That article got me good reviews later. In a sense, I am typically an undisciplined and non time bound amateur writer. But, I enjoy being so.

  • http://twitter.com/CalebGriffin Caleb Griffin

    I find that writing a short outline of my blog posts days ahead of time allows the idea to germinate so that when I return to the writing it flows more easily.

  • http://twitter.com/ajeanne Jeanne Farrington

    When I’m working on an article, and I’ve written those pesky paragraphs that just don’t work, I create a separate document called “Pieces.” I move the rejected paragraphs or chunks over to that document, just in case I can use them later. This way, I don’t feel like I’ve been wasting my time, and occasionally, those paragraphs become the seed of a new article or post.

    • http://www.3hatscommunications.com davinabrewer

      I do a version of this, keep so many posts and sections in “draft” mode. I make a point to revisit them from time to time, make sure I’m not repeating the same thoughts, or at least updating them to stay topical.

  • David

    There are times when writing just flows out my fingers on the keyboard like water downhill. Then there are the other times it is like I’m carrying a piano on my back alone up three flights of old wooden stairs. The easy times always seem to come from inspiration of a “God Moment”, or the catching a glimpse of God in anothers life. They may not even see it happening as they are just being servants to one of God less fortunate in this lifetime.

    Sometimes it is something that one of the many animals that we have had over the years or now have did. How they showed their unconditional love towards us as does God. I have found out when I stand back and get “me” out of the way to tell anothers story I write like a maniac. I can always tell when it is inspiration verses perspiration. Because when I am done with inspiration I don’t want to change one word, and I am physically exhausted. When it is perspiration writing I end up reading it over and over changing a word here or a thought there. I even sense then that I am frustrated as does anyone in earshot. Many times I need to just walk away to come back later to finish it.

    The only exception I have personally found to this is when the Lord is really developing an idea or deep thought in me. It is as thought He is bringing it to my heart as well as up form my inner well at the same time. Those times take a lot more meditation with perspiration on the old pump handle before I see any water flowing out. But when it freely flows, and it does, it is cool, sweet, and satisfies the thirsting of my soul. I Hope this helps as it works for me. Whatever it takes keep writing as the Lord will bless what you put your hands to if you will give your heart and whole being to Him. God Bless…..David/ New Vision Ministries

  • Anonymous

    I keep a running list of all the post topics I thought would be slam dunks, but they weren’t. We’re all going to run head first into that wall. I have had many an ideas that I just couldn’t flesh out. Some of them have become really great posts, but some haven’t. I still have them written down, but they aren’t at the top of my topics list simply because I don’t have the inspiration for them.

    I’ll get to them eventually, but for now, they can just relax — they’ll come around and once they do, I will write like crazy.

  • Pingback: Sometimes Starting is the Hardest Part - Faith Experience

  • Gail

    I find that the best thing to help me get into the creative zone is to do something physical like take a walk, weed the garden or play foozball. For some reason this kicks me into a space where the ideas and words start to flow again. Great for problem solving, releasing writers block, not so good for winning foozball games 8-S

    • http://www.3hatscommunications.com davinabrewer

      I’ll clean, do laundry, dishes.. something active that helps remove the clutter and distractions.

  • http://www.christopherscottblog.typepad.com/ Christopher Scott

    Yes,
    I have learned to trust the process.

    My process is to always outline my writing before sitting at a computer. This allows me to always have something to write about, and it prevents me from getting stuck. Plus, when I begin writing what I have outlined, I seem to have more ideas flow to me that I can write about.

    Writing feels easy most of the time, but when it becomes difficult, I just keep writing. I keep cranking out words until I have nothing left in me.

  • http://www.3hatscommunications.com davinabrewer

    Michael, Don’t have a great writer’s quote to share, probably should look into that. My holdups are not so much writing as publishing, per my writing goals and basic discipline. I could type the days away, writing about hobbies, about fun things I enjoy, about things that irritate or annoy. But that’s not always gonna cut it, as I write and blog for my business. So when that pressure is on to share something new, write some deep, insightful perspective on social media and PR that enhances my personal brand, professional reputation (feel free to role your eyes, I did), that’s when the fear hits.. causing slacker “do it later” undisciplined tendencies to take hold. So I need to do less of Step 2, and a lot more of Step 1. Thanks for the motivation.

  • Pingback: The Random Me blog post | Marketing, Public Relations and Social Media Blog | Atlanta, GA

  • http://3-18ministries.blogspot.com Tory Satter

    I have only been blogging for about 5 months. Last month I had a post that just took off (and it wasn’t even one of my favorite posts!). When all was said and done I think it was shared on Facebook around 30 times. I found myself struggling to write anything for the next week because I wasn’t sure to how “top” the previous post. I finally just sat down and started again, but it was tough.

  • http://tomstuart.org Tom Stuart

    I had exactly the same thing happen this morning. Seldom do I have to walk away from my thrice weekly practice of writing my blog. But today I did. Like you I just hit the wall. When I came back three hours later it miraculously all fell into place. Thanks for the encouragment.

  • Tim

    I believe you nailed it. You just have to trust the process. I found that to be true in writing Every Day is Game Day, The CHILD Game Plan, and The Street Sweeper. I have also had to trust the process many times in writing blog posts for Irrefutable Success. Getting stuck will happen… It’s a wonderful feeling to get un-stuck as the ideas begin to flow.

  • http://woodworking-books.org Best Woodworking Plans

    Mike – love this post. I chuckled as I reflected on my own challenges here.

  • http://pocketpurposeblog.wordpress.com Carlene Byron

    The more seriously I take myself as a writer, the more ways I record what I’m thinking and seeing and the more of my time I’m writing and recording — in notebooks, on the laptop, and in long cellphone messages to myself while I’m driving (until I get used to the digital recorder that’s Dragon compatible). And the more stuff I record, the more stuff I will eventually have to throw away, I’m sure. I always tell students that they should plan on throwing out 95 percent of what they put on paper … that writing is one way to get your thoughts outside yourself and think them through, and it can take a while to figure out how to say what you really want to say.

  • http://twitter.com/BLichtenwalner Ben Lichtenwalner

    I don’t know what you’re talking about. I’ve never had that problem… and, if you believe that, I have a bridge I want to sell you.

    What helps – though it’s still not great – is when I lose my muse or the words just are not coming, I use that time to tweak the website, read other blogs and contribute through comments or other feedback. The result is a feeling I’ve at least been productive – even if I did not get that post or chapter written.

    Love that quote by P.J. O’Rourke by the way!

  • Scopwife

    After years of beating myself up for “not writing” I came to the slow realization that you are indeed writing all the time: eavesdropping on a conversation at the grocery store, listening to music, taking in a scene, etc. —and once I discovered that, I decided that the down time is just as important! Sometimes when I walk away from it, I come back with so much more…
    Write on!
    SCW Stella
    http://suddenlycopwife.blogspot.com/

  • http://jeffgoins.myadventures.org Jeff Goins

    Yup, been there… many, MANY nights. I find that as a writer, the best thing I can do to “get inspired” is to just show up. If I wait for inspiration, it comes intermittently and inconsistently. If I show up, inspiration eventually comes.

    That said, when I DO feel inspired, I’ve learned to stop everything that I’m doing and at least take some notes, because when the Muse comes upon me suddenly, it can often mean a profound thought that may leave if I don’t jot something down.

  • http://www.chrismanion.com Chris Manion

    I made a file once titled “To Order.” In it went pages from magazines or newspapers that had something I thought I wanted to buy. I’d review that file from time to time and find that I could dismiss most of its contents . It was a way to get me past distractions and onto core values. The process of writing is like that for me sometimes.

    We just have to show up. God works with us in the process. But we must stand before the door (laptop) before it will open.

    It’s also like golf. You can’t play it unless you get yourself to the golf course. Then there’s all sorts of routines to get ready, to warm up, practice shots, banter, and finally, a ball on the tee and a club in the hand. It’s not wasted time all the shifting of our weight, checking our swing, wiggling our hips. It’s all part of the process. On the occasions you can’t hit diddly squat, you go home early and call it a day.

  • http://twitter.com/BLichtenwalner Ben Lichtenwalner

    For me, if the creative juices are not flowing, I do one of the following:
    1. Work on the site (tweak this or that, find that plugin I saw on someone’s site, etc…)
    2. Read other blogs and comment
    3. Note ideas and outlines for other posts, when the creativity and flow is there

    The result is a still productive use of the time, even if I can’t keep the focus or creative energy on the content I originally intended. I also loved John’s suggestions on walking around – that will help a lot as well.

  • http://musicroad.blogspot.com kerrydexter

    yes, I’ve learned to trust the process, and also trust that for me, my most productive writing time is often spent thinking, rather than writing.

  • Pingback: Words on a page » Blog Archive » A few links for the end of the week - A blog about writing, in its various forms

  • http://juliesunne.com/ Julie Sunne

    My problem is I have small windows of writing time. Inspiration usually doesn’t strike during those times, and when I finally sit down to put my ideas on screen, the words have moved on. Frustrating.  I believe much of the cause of my brain freezes though is that I’m still a relatively new online writer and am lacking confidence to just let the words flow. Thanks for another great article.

  • http://twitter.com/karenzach Karen Zacharias

    I’m going to try sorting the neckties next. My husband must have 200 of them. If this works, then if I don’t get the next book written, at least the closets will be more organized. 

    • http://theordainedbarista.com/ Barry Hill

      Karen,
      This made me laugh.

  • http://twitter.com/DainDunston Dain Dunston

    I was at a conference once when someone said from the stage, “If you’re a real writer, you write everyday.” Wow, I thought, I must not be a real writer. And then I thought, that’s nonsense! I don’t run every day. I don’t work every day. Sometimes, I don’t eat and sleep every day. Sometimes you have to step away from the desk. If you’re a “real writer” the desk will always pull you back. 

    Horton Foote (The Trip to Bountiful, Tender Mercies) told me about this story he couldn’t finish, about a young couple who weren’t allowed to marry and so, for the rest of their lives she would sit on her porch every morning and evening and he would walk by on his way to work. But Horton couldn’t find the way to turn that into a play. He gave up and put it in the drawer. Ten years later, it became the seed for (and a story within) The Trip to Bountiful.

    I once quit writing for nearly five years, but it didn’t take. If you’re a writer, you’ll write.

  • Suzyomalley1

    By no means am I a professional writer. I did hear the author of Eat Pray Love speak once and she said the best advice she ever received was from her sister who told her to write as if she was telling the story to one specific person she knew. With this person in mind you could just start talking to them and it makes the writing more personal and intimate to any reader. It works.

  • Robin

    What’s worse is when you get a lot of other things done except for the writing you really want (and need) to do. I can only feel good about those kind of days so long as someone doesn’t come along & ask me how much writing I got done…

  • Scsiders

    I’ve been here a million times and just sitting down and writing anyway usually works. I once wrote about not knowing what to say and it became this lovely prose piece. It’s always shocking what happens.

  • Tim Krupa

    I would agree. I would also add another “block.” There are times when I believe there is no one who wants to read what I have to say.

    Tim

  • David Manning

    Trust the Muse!