I tell you, sir,” he whispered, “it is the end of the world. Never were known such excesses of the scholars: it is the cursed inventions of the age that ruin everything: artillery, serpentines, bombards, and above all, printing, that other pestilence from Germany. No more manuscripts! No more books! Printing is cutting up the bookselling trade. The end of the world is certainly at hand!”
Disclosure of Material Connection: Some of the links in the post above are “affiliate links.” This means if you click on the link and purchase the item, I will receive an affiliate commission. Regardless, I only recommend products or services I use personally and believe will add value to my readers. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255: “Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising.”
Ha, I love Charlie Chaplin’s quote about movies being a fad and people will want to see flesh & blood theater.
http://michaelhyatt.com Michael Hyatt
It is. I really would love to find a series of quotes, suggesting that various technologies were going to kill off books or reading/
http://relevantbrokenness.com Marni Arnold
Fear is such a wild emotion to explore – it is easy to spot, but so incapable of being logically explained.
EJ Wesley
History is, and will always be, the best teacher.
Karl Mealor
Don’t remember hearing this on the Disney version!
I have wondered about the consequence of e-books. Most books can be purchased for $7.99 or less. Does that allow for enough profit to make it financially feasible for good writers to continue writing? Or will we see a revival of the classics, similar to what has happened in the music industry? I teach high school, and the kids have the same music on their iPods and iPhones that I listened to when I was their age.
TNeal
Interesting to note inventions that expand a person’s reach-the printing press, radio, television, cell phones-almost always have a buyer-beware warning label attached. The statement that the printing press would be “cutting up the bookselling trade” astounds me. A review of history proves the opposite.
http://twitter.com/obihaive Joseph Sanchez
Is the character saying the printing press is killing all books or that the printing press should be stopped from making more books?
People are normally scared when they don’t understand something and change is required on their part. I’m sure the printing press would have been more accepted if people better understood the benefits that came from it. The same goes for today with things such as e-books and other technological advances.
http://michaelhyatt.com Michael Hyatt
I am not sure. I need to go back and read it in context.
A similar thing happened when mass paperbacks were first introduced. People thought it was the end of the publishing business. I assume this is because books would be so cheap, it would destroy the business model.
http://twitter.com/PFNikolai Pete Nikolai
The character seems to be commenting on how the mass distribution of books enables the rapid dissemination of thoughts that spur protests and other diversions to occupy people’s time rather than working on manuscripts. Hugo goes on to comment in chapter 2 “This Will Kill That” in Book Fifth of The Hunchback of Notre Dame on how different institutions reacted to the introduction of the printing press and how the printing press was killing architecture. He seems to be saying that the expression that previously went into architecture was being redirected to writing (and perhaps reading). Perhaps today we face a similar transition in which some of the time that previously was spent reading books is not spent reading other content and creating other content. http://www.online-literature.com/victor_hugo/hunchback_notre_dame/24/
http://twitter.com/ThatGuyKC K.C. Pro
It is funny to me how the heralding of impending doom (for the world or an industry) or blatant denial (like lying politicians or the success of a technology) seem to repeat themselves throughout history.
Thank you for sharing this nugget from a literary master.
http://twitter.com/B_Schebs B_Schebs
It makes me think if this statement might not have been more about the printing press’s ability to put books into the hands of everyone, and not just the rich and more educated?
http://www.christopherscottblog.typepad.com/ Christopher Scott
The end of the world?
If books are no longer published and censored, we just might find the end of the world coming.
Sounds a lot like the predictions about newspapers, magazines, radio, TV and now the internet.
Good writing will always survive and thrive.
Thanks
http://twitter.com/21tigermike Michael A. Robson
Mmm… Interesting. Remember, for every book that’s published, about 9,999 are turned down by publishers. Thankfully, we have the internet, and we have eBooks, which almost anyone can do. :P
http://forrest-long.blogspot.com Forrest Long
Interesting, as we listen today to those who say electronic publishing will soon end the traditional book publishing industry, as Amazon’s electronic book sales soar. The pundits have been wrong before. I like my Kindle, but I still like to hold a book in my hand and read it. It’s not an “either-or” situation, but a nervous co-existence.
http://twitter.com/MrDavidWillis David Willis
It seems with every change, fear would have us believe that things are as good as they are ever going to get. What was the actual result of the printing press? Books more easily made it into the hands of the common man giving him the opportunity to be more and do more than he ever did. What if things get better from here and not worse?
http://uma-maheswaran.blogspot.com/ Uma Maheswaran S
How crazy! As C.S. Lewis quotes, “The great thing is, if one can, to stop regarding all the unpleasant things as interruptions in one’s “own” or “real” life. The truth is, of course, that what one regards as interruptions are precisely one’s life.”
http://peterpollock.com Peter P
I think he might have had a point…..
Actually, seriously, I think he might have had a point.
The problem I find with books these days is that there’s simply too many of them,
http://www.thehahnhuntinglodge.com Nikole Hahn
I’m not anti-self-publishing, but I’m more for traditional publishing. To me, I interpret this quote to talk about just that…the fact that we have more books available than ever before. And I wonder…will the good writers be heard in all that noise?
http://twitter.com/slumbersixcon Joe Lalonde
I can see the term “printing press” being replaced by “ebook readers” in this quote.
I wonder how the new ebook readers will change the face of books. I love the ease and portability of them, including the vast amount of books you can store on them. I love being able to turn on the reader and choose any of the books I own on it. However, I struggle with the cost of purchasing ebooks. I see the lack of materials needed to print and feel the cost should drop due to that.
But I see a place for both physical and ebooks and I’m sure it will stay that way for quite some time.
http://www.digitalpost.ca/ Printing Calgary
That’s a great quote, especially considering that we’re a standing at yet another change of mediums. I just read a post about people still printing out papers to read off paper, not off screen. A little tool called joliprint helps you do that. The point is that we’re still humans and still love to read off paper. Thanks for stimulating a great discussion.
http://www.livingmartyrs.com brad
So, as we examine our current direction(s), I guess the big question is:
“Who are the scribes, and who are the publishers?”
It’s a time when anything is possible. That induces panic and euphoria in equal parts.
Anonymous
There was absolutely a agitation amidst theologians in the sixteenth aeon about the chastity of printing. I anticipate Brian Brock content book on the belief of technology references some of it.
This one is very best and amazing post and images.I like all images given in post.This all images are very cool.
fabio faron
I agree. The great thing is, if one can, to stop regarding all the unpleasant things as interruptions in one’s “own” or “real” life. The truth is the book isn’t dieing, it’s simply diversifying into print and digital forms. What is changing is power.
These are the amazing people who help moderate my comments and provide leadership to our growing community.
MICHELE CUSHATT is a communicator and storyteller whose speaking experience includes Women of Faith, Focus on the Family, and Compassion International. As emcee and communication coach, Michele is in her sixth year on staff at Dynamic Communicators International. She lives in Colorado with her husband Troy and three teenage sons. You can connect with Michele on her blog, Facebook, or Twitter.
BARRY HILL, JR. is a storyteller, blogger, speaker, barista, and is in his fifteenth year of full-time ministry to teens and their families. He lives in Northern Virginia with his wife, Rachel, and their six children—“the circus.” You can usually find Barry where fresh coffee and good ideas are brewing. To join in the conversation, drop by his blog, The Ordained Barista, visit him on Facebook, or follow him on Twitter.
JOE LALONDE is a husband, explorer, challenger, and an adrenaline junkie. He has served as a youth leader for E3 Ministries for over 10 years. He is usually found wandering the woods, enjoying the company of his wife, or running the trails. Joe enjoys helping others expand their influence and leadership skills. You can connect with Joe at his blog or Twitter.
RACHEL LANCE is originally from Alaska but now lives in a Chicago suburb with her husband and daughter. She works in technology and communications for the Willow Creek Association. She holds a degree in information management and is working on her Master’s in Library Science. Given the gift of time, top on her list would be a long bike ride, a great novel, and a farmer’s market dinner. Follow her on Twitter.
JIM MARTIN is the minister of Crestview Church of Christ in Waco, Texas, where he has served since 1994. He also leads a mentoring group, primarily composed of younger Christian leaders, and serves as a Mentoring Partner for MentorNetwork Ministry. He and his wife, Charlotte, have been married for 33 years. Read his blog, A Place for the God-Hungry, and follow him on Twitter.
TIM PETERS is the Co-Founder of Resolute Creative, a digital marketing group. He loves seeing organizations of all sizes come alive when they identify the best digital solutions to advance their cause. Tim enjoys working out, running marathons, playing golf and spending time with his wife and three kids. Connect with him on his blog, follow him Twitter or connect with him via LinkedIn.
JASON STAMBAUGH is a husband, father, former fat kid, accidental techie, and founder of Wevival and Shop My Church. Jason also blogs at Heart Your Church about church ministry in the social media era. When he’s not helping customers, or working on his latest project, you will find him hanging with his family, reading, learning to code, cooking, hobby farming, and exercising. Connect with him on Twitter and Google +.
JEREMY STATTON is an orthopedic surgeon in Louisville, KY. Although he enjoys writing, reading, and running, his first love is his wife and four kids. His family is currently in the process of adopting a son from China. He is also the author of Grace Is: A Practical Guide to God’s Love. He is an avid blogger at JeremyStatton.com focusing on helping others live a better story. Follow him on Twitter.
JOHN TILLER is an inspirational speaker and writer. He travels with his family to churches, conferences, and other events sharing their remarkable survival story. He enjoys real estate investing, serving at his home church, watching NFL and NASCAR, improving his 10K time, and hanging out with his family at their Powhatan, Virginia home. Connect with John via blog, Facebook, or Twitter.
JUSTIN WISE is the social strategist for Monk Development, builders of Ekklesia 360. A proud husband and dad, Justin and his family live in Des Moines, Iowa. When not running, reading, or cooking, find him blogging at JustinWise.net, online at Justin.am, or on Twitter.
Pingback: Tweets that mention Why the Printing Press Will Kill Books -- Topsy.com